When Does Frugality Start Costing You Money? – Episode 694

Spencer Shaw kicks off by asking when frugality begins to cost money, and Kim Butler answers with a driveway. Relatives of hers poured one too tight for anyone to turn around in. In the family’s big farm truck she can’t do it safely without taking out bushes and trees or hitting the house, so she gets close and finishes on foot. Kim’s own driveway came at an awkward moment, the end of the build with money and time both tight, and a very large one still won out. She calls it a horrific expense and says she’s grateful for it more times than she can count. She gets it, she says: sometimes nothing can be done about it, yet it remains a choice, and choices sometimes have unintended consequences. Spencer follows with a friend’s concrete job. The friend balked at the cost of extra gravel, so the concrete had to level things out and the final bill grew. Kim then moves the lesson to money. She points to how many people cash out their 401(k)s and 403s after leaving a job, or after being asked to go. They know a 10% penalty is waiting for anyone under 59 and a half, with taxes on top. Kim adds that the taxes can’t be dodged, since they come due on those dollars eventually. People pay up because they have no emergency fund. She faults them, and she faults the financial services industry too, because every single 22- or 23-year-old fresh out of school gets talked into a 401(k) contribution or a 403, and most employers enroll people automatically. The result is young workers with neither emergency money nor liquidity. Kim’s remedy is an emergency opportunity fund, which lets the other dollars stay invested, and she says people need one their entire lives. Spencer wants to know what Kim happily overpays for. Her husband pays up for quality tools, she says, and detours to Harbor Freight only for a tool he’ll use once or twice. She detests overpaying herself, yet one thing her dad told her long ago stuck: when furnishing anything from a dorm room to a 10,000 square foot palace, put the money into what you sit on, sleep on, or walk on, and not into everything else, such as the lamps, drapes, and art. Then the talk moves to lean years and green years, which Kim says show up especially in entrepreneurial households and which she shares with W-2 households too. She wants kids in on that conversation. She adds that some spending is helpful to a family’s life, and a sports-heavy family buying food on the road, which is sometimes the best thing to do, is one example, yet she sees an unbelievable amount of money going to sports drinks. Spencer’s last question is when frugality creates scarcity, and Kim goes to clothing. Buying cheap, as opposed to inexpensive, is the problem, she says, since frayed hems and mismatched stripes in front of a prospect invite a judgment you’ll probably have a hard time coming back from. Cheap and inexpensive aren’t the same thing. Spencer closes with a Reddit thread on once-frugal things that got pricey, with no mention in the comments of finance or an emergency fund, and ties it back to having reserves, so that a transition doesn’t mean a tax penalty. Show Notes
  • Spencer’s opening carries a quick apology to Kim for saying the word plan.
  • Spencer’s friend had the concrete job measured and dialed in. Skimping on the gravel is the move Spencer says you should never make.
  • Spencer asks whether Kim has seen the same pattern in money, someone short on wisdom who got lost and paid more for it.
  • Kim says people take the penalty with open eyes: they know it’s coming and pay it to get the cash. The young workers she describes include 18-year-old homeschoolers who already have a college degree by the time they finish high school.
  • These workers figure a credit card is the backup. Kim says sure, you can tap one, yet a job change down the road is likely to bring a stretch of bills with no income.
  • Kim says that with every dollar in those plans, the tax on that money will probably always come at the highest brackets, with a potential penalty on top and no money to weather the storm.
  • Kim read a book she calls fabulous on distributing the money, a subject she says nobody talks about, yet it skipped cash and where to keep it. Cash frustrates people because of its rate of return, she says. If the amount you need is $10,000, $100,000, or some other figure, and it earns zero, her view is to let it, so the rest can stay invested.
  • It doesn’t have to earn zero, she adds. She cites a net, net, net 4 1/2% inside the cash value of a whole life insurance policy and calls it emergency opportunity money, and if that doesn’t appeal, the bank is fine: it won’t hurt, and she says it will help from the short run to the long.
  • Her husband sticks to Lowe’s, Home Depot, or Sears for quality tools. Kim says her dad’s furnishing rule has stuck with her, and it has been valuable to the whole family.
  • Spencer describes Kim’s upbringing as responsibility rather than extreme frugality. Kim says her parents were teachers and there wasn’t a lot of income in the house, though the farm gave them tax benefits, and in the ’70s and ’80s the family ate out maybe once a month.
  • Lean years and green years is advice Kim has shared before, and she offers it to W-2 families too, for instance after a job loss while the other partner still works.
  • On sports drinks, Kim sets the energy drink debate aside and goes straight to Gatorade versus water. If times are lean, she suggests bringing water plus your own powdered electrolytes, if you feel you need them, and putting the money into quality food so the players are fueled.
  • Kim says quality clothes now cost a third of what they once did, and she’s talking quality, not name brand. A $2,000 suit isn’t required, yet she says spending $50 on one probably falls short.
  • Spencer’s Reddit thread asked what used to be underpriced or frugal and no longer is, and people answered with chicken wings, brisket, and thrifting. He invites listeners to email what they’ve been thinking about on frugality or their family’s budget to hello@prosperitythinkers.com.
Quotes
  1. Kim Butler (00:01:55): “As we know, choices sometimes have unintended consequences.”
  2. Kim Butler (00:02:55): “You’re always going to pay the taxes on retirement dollars at some point.”
  3. Kim Butler (00:04:20): “Everybody’s talking about growing the money, not how to get it out.”
  4. Kim Butler (00:05:40): “People need emergency opportunity funds their entire lives.”
  5. Kim Butler (00:06:50): “Spend money on things that you sit on, sleep on, and walk on.”
  6. Kim Butler (00:08:20): “Talk to your kids about lean years and green years.”
  7. Kim Butler (00:10:10): “Spend money on quality food so that you’re fueled so that you can play your sports properly.”
  8. Kim Butler (00:11:45): “In today’s world, we do absolutely judge a book by its cover.”
Do you have a question you would like answered on the show? Please send it to us at hello@prosperitythinkers.com and we may answer it in an upcoming episode.
Read the full transcript

Transcript provided by the show’s production team.

[00:00] Spencer Shaw: Prosperity Thinkers, welcome to the podcast. We’re gonna be talking about when frugality starts costing us money. Uh, we’ve, we’ve touched on this before, and we’ve seen people move things around and want to, oh, I’m sorry to use this word, Kim, plan things. I know. Um, but, uh, let’s talk about this. When does frugality start to cost us money? Kim Butler: Well, I have a great example. Um, there are family members that chose to pour a concrete driveway, and it is so small you cannot turn around in it. It is the biggest pain in the entire world. Like, I don’t even wanna go down their driveway. Like, we live on a country road, right? Like, I, I get in the area and then I just walk the rest of the way because it’s just with our big farm truck, I cannot, I cannot turn around in it safely, y- you know, in a way that I’m comfortable without

[01:00] knocking over bushes, trees, hitting the house, whatever. And I get it, right? Like, when we chose to pour our concrete driveway, it was a horrific expense. It was not at a good time. We were at the end of our build and money was tight, time was tight, like everything was tight. But we chose a very large concrete driveway, and I cannot tell you how many times I am grateful for that. So I get it. You know, sometimes there’s nothing that you can do about it, and yet it is a choice. And as we know, choices sometimes have unintended consequences Spencer Shaw: Yes, they do. You know, that’s funny. So I, uh, as you mentioned that, I have an, a similar concrete experience, and I think it will play into what we’re gonna talk about with some finances. So, uh, I have a friend that had a concrete project,

[02:00] and they did the one thing that you should never do, and it’s this. They, they went, they measured it out, they had it all dialed in, they put the gravel down, but they didn’t put enough gravel and get the gravel leveled properly. So, because they didn’t wanna pay the expense for that extra gravel, Kim Butler: Right Spencer Shaw: ended up paying more because the concrete had to do that leveling. So have you seen that same thing happen with people’s finances where they didn’t have the wisdom and they got lost and it ended up costing them more? Kim Butler: Yeah. Well, just look at the statistics for how many people cash out their retirement plans, right? 401s, 403s. People leave their job, or they’re asked to leave, and they know that they’re gonna pay a 10% penalty because they’re under 59 and a half, and taxes. But you can’t get away from the taxes. You’re always gonna pay the taxes on retirement dollars at some point. Nevertheless, they will pay the 10%

[03:00] penalty to get the money because they had no emergency fund. And I, I definitely feel like, okay, bad on them, but bad on the financial services industry, because every single 22-year-old or 23-year-old that’s out of school, or, you know, these days 18-year-olds that homeschool and by the time they’re out of high school they’ve got all their college degree and they’re ready to go to work, what are they talked into? A 401(k) contribution or a 403. And as we know, most employers have those automated systems in place where you’re enrolled whether you like it or not. These kids have no emergency money. They have no liquidity. They think, “Oh, I can tap a credit card.” Yes, you can, but the fact is, down the road when you are going to change jobs, there is likely gonna be a period of time where you need to pay for bills and you have no income. And if all of your dollars are put into retirement plans, not only will

[04:00] you probably always pay tax at the highest brackets, because that’s the way retirement dollars work, but you also will potentially have to pay a penalty because you will not have any money to weather the storm. And you know, we get so frustrated by our cash because we think it’s not doing anything. And I just read a book recently that was a fabulous book about what you do in your retirement years to distribute the money, because nobody’s ever talking about that, right? Everybody’s talking about growing the money, not how to get it out. But that person was even neglectful in talking about the importance of cash and furthermore, good places to store that cash, because like I said, everybody gets frustrated on rate of return. Well, if you need 10,000, 100,000, whatever your number is that’s earning zero, then let it be so that all of

[05:00] your other dollars can stay invested. However, you don’t have to let it earn zero. You can let it earn net, net, net 4 1/2% in a whole life insurance policy as cash value, and let that be your emergency opportunity money. But for whatever reason, if you don’t like that, just let it sit in the bank. It’s not gonna hurt you, and it will actually help you, not only in the short run, in the medium run, in the long run. Like, people need emergency opportunity funds their entire lives. Spencer Shaw: Absolutely. You, you make a really good point of, of the accumulation. Everyone’s talking about that, but they’re not talking about how to have that money exit and leave properly. So on the term of frugality that we’re talking here, I have a couple questions for you. So I’m super curious, which is this: um, what do you happily overpay for now?

[06:00] Kim Butler: That’s a good question. So my husband is a better example of this because he will happily overpay for tools, right? He wants quality tools, so we go to Lowe’s or Home Depot or Sears, and he gets quality tools. On occasion, he will know that a tool is basically a one or two-use tool, and so he will go to Harbor Freight and get the cheap tool, right? Because he knows that it doesn’t matter. I’m not a good example of that. I detest overpaying for things. Um, but I do remember something that my dad said to me so long ago, and this has actually been valuable to us as a family, and it’s whenever you’re dealing with furnishing a home, whether it’s a dorm room or a 10,000 square foot palace, doesn’t really matter. Spend money on things that you

[07:00] sit on, sleep on, and walk on, and don’t spend money on everything else, the lamps, the drapes, the art, et cetera. So that has always, always stuck in my head Spencer Shaw: Ooh, I like that. Okay, so, uh, you’ve seen it from your husband Todd’s perspective, and you grew up in a house where we’re not gonna say extreme frugality, but I would say responsibility. Is that, is that a good way of putting it? Kim Butler: Oh, yeah. My parents were teachers. I mean, there was not a lot of income in the house. Of course, we had the farm, and so that gave them a lot of tax benefits. But I mean, we… And you know, it was a different era, right? So this is like the ’70s and ’80s. We went out to eat maybe once a month, maybe Spencer Shaw: So that leads to the next question that I

[08:00] have right here on the list, which is: What expenses look wasteful but actually increase prosperity? Kim Butler: I love it. So I first have to say that there, especially in an entrepreneurial households, are lean years and green years, and I have shared this wisdom before, but I think it’s so helpful, and I even share it with W-2 people, especially, like, if somebody’s lost a job, you know, the other partner’s still working, but whatever. Talk to your kids about lean years and green years. Now, that being said, there are things that we spend time on because they are helpful to our lives. And so, for example, a heavy-duty sports-oriented family that’s going, going, going, or art, you know, or dance or whatever it is, is absolutely gonna get some value out of purchasing food on the run, and there are times that that is the best thing to do.

[09:00] But they can also not have to just, um, fall into that 100%. So, for example, and I, I may have shared this actually recently, because I think it’s so helpful to people. The sports drinks space is insane these days. First of all, we could debate whether energy drinks are even appropriate for kids, but scrap the energy drink conversation. Just go for the, like, the Gatorade versus water, right? And I get it. Yes, there are some electrolytes and et cetera, et cetera. But that space and the unbelievable amount of money that gets spent under the guise of, “We’re in a hurry. We can’t do anything else.” Food, I get it, but you can still pack food from home. Nevertheless, sometimes there’s nothing you can do. You’re on the road, whatever. But drinks don’t have to be that way, and drinks are so expensive. So it’s one of those spaces where if

[10:00] times are lean, then bring water with your own powdered electrolyte stuff if that’s really what you feel like you need to have, but then go ahead and spend money on quality food so that you’re fueled so that you can play your sports properly. I think that’s maybe a good example Spencer Shaw: Yeah, I think so. So the, the final question I have on this list is, you know, when does frugality create scarcity? And what’s the check and balance that maybe you could say, “Watch out for this or that”? Kim Butler: Yeah. So, um, another family example, um, clothing is an interesting one, and you know, thankfully today, clothes– you can get high quality clothes for a third of the price that we used to have to pay for stuff. And I’m talking quality, I’m not talking name brand. Like c- for me, I could care less what the name brand is, but I wasn’t always that way. It, it used to matter to me.

[11:00] But the space of, well, I don’t have a lot of money, so I’m gonna go cheap with clothing in a cheap way, not an inexpensive way, is problematic because then when you go to that meeting and you’re sitting with another business owner, for example, or a client or a prospect, better word, that you’re asking to do business with, if your stripes don’t match and your hem is frayed and, you know, other things that appear in cheap clothing, there’s a judgment call on that that you’re probably gonna have a hard time coming back from. And it’s unfortunate, you know, in today’s world, we do absolutely judge a book by its cover and so it’s just something that you have to be aware of. And it doesn’t mean that you need a $2,000 suit, but it probably means that you shouldn’t spend 50 bucks on it either Spencer Shaw: Oh, that makes sense. You know, you, you’re mentioning this

[12:00] in my, my final tie-in. I was reading a Reddit post recently in my research for this, and it was people saying, “Hey, what is something that used to be underpriced or enjoyable or frugal that is no longer?” And people piped up and they said, “Cooking chicken wings or brisket,” stuff like that. Cuts of meat that used to be ec- like economically cheap meats or whatever are expensive now. And you mentioned clothes, and people now go thrifting and thrift prices are high. But there’s– It was funny because in the comments, there was nowhere in there about finance, nowhere in there about emergency fund, nowhere in there about laying down a foundation and really taking care of the important things. So what you shared today, uh, the lean years, the

[13:00] green years, the foundation of us approaching things, having the reserves so that if we do have a transition, we’re not taking that tax penalty and we’re getting our money to work for us, incredibly helpful. For any of you listeners, if there are things that you’ve thought about, frugality or trying to figure out how to navigate with your family’s budget or whatever that is, send an email to hello@prosperitythinkers.com.

Interested in Life Insurance?

Our Team Loves to Help People Buy Whole Life Insurance and Term Insurance.

Click here to book a free call to find out your options.

Special Listener Gift

Download our eBook: Activating Your Prosperity Guide. 

Kim Butler’s groundbreaking eBook/ audiobook explains why typical financial advice may be sabotaging your wealth… and what to do instead!

Subscribe

Subscribe on your favorite podcast player to get the latest episodes.

If you like what you hear please leave a review by clicking here.